The debate we should not have lost

Wednesday, September 2, 2026

View in browser
One thing that frustrates me -- deeply -- is when the side with the worse argument nevertheless wins a debate.

I've seen it happen quite a bit. In 2018 I took daughter Regina, then 15, with me to a Soho Forum debate on a particular kind of originalism: whether the Constitution should be interpreted according to the original meaning of the document as conveyed by the words of the text.

(Let's leave aside that genuine originalism involves original intent, not just the words in isolation, but even this version of the argument sure beats the progressive "we'll interpret it so it lets us do what we want, and we'll keep you posted on its changing meaning every day" argument.)

The debate was between Georgetown University Law Center's Randy Barnett, whom I don't agree with entirely but who gets a lot right, and Cornell Law School's Michael Dorf, who doesn't.

Even though Barnett doesn't represent my precise position, I was rooting for him. Unfortunately, he didn't look impressive. His arguments weren't organized and compelling. He didn't come across as someone in command of the room.

Unfortunately, Michael Dorf did. Charming, funny, articulate, and somehow more convincing, even though he was totally wrong.

So the audience voted, and even in a libertarian setting, Dorf was declared the winner.

History is full of perfectly correct people who lost to worse ideas that were simply delivered better. You know that's true. You've seen it. And you've probably felt it, too: you have something worth saying and it isn't landing.

This is not primarily about winning debates per se. Most people never participate in a formal debate, and don't need debate training.

I'm speaking of a larger issue, that applies to huge numbers of people. Successful people have usually mastered every skill except this one: they can build the company, but they freeze when asked to explain it to 200 people. There is a quiet humiliation in being the smartest, most accomplished person in the room, and the least able to show it. 

I'm talking about (to name only a handful of examples):
  • The surgeon who can't get the hospital board to fund the thing that would save lives, because the finance people out-talked him.
  • The founder whose product is genuinely better but keeps losing deals to a rival with a slicker pitch.
  • The person raising money for a venture who has the numbers but can't make the room feel the opportunity.
  • The researcher sitting on important work that never gets attention because the paper is impenetrable and the talk is worse.
  • The person with unpopular-but-correct views who gets dismissed not because the argument is weak but because the delivery is.
  • The author with a finished book and no ability to talk about it, watching lesser books outsell it on the strength of the author's charisma.
  • The financial advisor whose advice is sound but who can't get clients to actually act on it.
  • The expert consultant who loses the pitch to someone half as competent but twice as clear.
I've spent 30 years learning to make ideas land, in front of audiences both hostile and friendly. (Many people reading this right now first came across me via a YouTube video of one of my speeches.) Next week in a free presentation I'm going to show you how I do it, with examples drawn from my own speeches.

This is an asset that Warren Buffett (whose father, by the way, Congressman Howard Buffett, was an early Murray Rothbard fan) says will last you 50 or 60 years -- and that if you don't have it, you'd better believe that lack will follow you for 50 or 60 years.

I'm only doing this live, no recording, so click here to reserve your spot and let's make you someone who commands a room (and enjoys all the benefits that come with that) rather than simply occupying it:
 
Tom Woods
 






This email was sent to dianaaudrey@gmail.com
why did I get this?    unsubscribe from this list    update subscription preferences
Tom Woods · PO Box 701447 · Saint Cloud, FL 34770 · USA

posted by Diana Audrey at 5:18 PM 0 comments

Hot deal alert! Cruises from $279

Last-minute savings you can’t skip
Browser View
 PLAN A CRUISE    ROYAL CARIBBEAN LOGO    CRUISE DEALS 
LAST MINUTES DEALS
JW
VY
OV
MA
HM
SR
EN
RD
RH
IC
BOA BANNER
SHOP_NOW_FOOTER_CTA
TERMS & CONDITIONS

All ship features, experiences and itineraries are subject to change without notice.

*Price is per person, in USD, cruise only, applies to select sailings, interior stateroom, based on double-occupancy, and reflects any promotional savings.

Last Minute Cruises applies to new individual bookings made on the sailings listed under "Last Minute Cruises" under the Deals section of www.RoyalCaribbean.com and provides discounted pricing at the rates displayed. Last Minute Cruises sailings are combinable with Free 3rd and 4th Guests, Kids Sail Free, Next Cruise Offers, Email Bonus Offer, Employee Friends & family and Crown and Anchor discounts but are NOT combinable with any other offer or promotion, including but not limited to BOGO60, Promotional OBCs, Instant savings, Promo Code driven offers, Restricted discounts (e.g. Seniors, Residents, Military), Shareholder Benefits, Standard Group, Interline, Travel Agent, Travel Agent Friends and Family, Weekly Sales Events and Net rates. Individual reservations may not be transferred into an existing group. Failure to apply the required full deposit amount may result in a cancellation of the booking. Last Minute Cruises is available to residents of United States, Canada, Puerto Rico, and select countries. Prices and offers are subject to availability and change without notice; capacity controlled and may be withdrawn at any time. Refer to www.RoyalCaribbean.com for additional terms and conditions. Royal Caribbean International reserves the right to correct any errors, inaccuracies, or omissions and to change or update fares, fees, and surcharges at any time without prior notice.

Jewel of the Seas, Voyager of the Seas, Mariner of the Seas, Harmony of the Seas, Freedom of the Seas, Serenade of the Seas, Enchantment of the Seas, Radiance of the Seas, Rhapsody of the Seas, Icon of the Seas, Perfect Day and Cococay are trademarks of Royal Caribbean.

posted by Diana Audrey at 9:25 AM 0 comments